Scientific news and articles
Male pipefish decide who survives
Saturn's rings a chaotic clutter
Researchers develop desal on a chip
Final missing piece of insulin lock found
Volcano helped dinosaurs gain upper hand
Bouncing current could speed up charge
Bleaching leaves Lord Howe reef 'on knife edge'
Floor price for booze good as taxes, study
Concerns over varroa mite resistance
Microbes breathe life into oxygen theory
Pre-history rewritten as new human discovered
Dung beetle claims strongest insect title
Scientists unearth Australian tyrannosaur
Splitting cyclone reveals Neptune's nature
Junk food can become addictive: study
Bumblebees have superfast colour vision
Black holes may be 'missing dark matter'
Magnets can manipulate morality: study
Sun helps bats find home in the dark
LHC to begin 'Big Bang' project
Trial of bionic eye within three years
Easter eggs may be good for your heart
Mega-flood triggered European ice age
Finch genome music to researcher's ears
Researchers question use of silver dressings
Costly silver dressings should not be routinely used on wounds until there is better evidence to support their use, say UK researchers.

But some experts insist silver dressings are an essential tool in treating burn wounds.

An evaluation published today in the Drug and Therapeutics Bulletin concludes that the UK National Health Service expenditure on silver dressings is "difficult to justify in the light of existing data".

"Silver dressings are expensive and there have been few high-quality clinical trials to establish whether they have advantages over other, cheaper, alternatives," says the Bulletin.

"Most of the studies that have been conducted have had considerable methodological limitations."

The Bulletin says routine use of silver dressings is not justified on clinical or cost-effectiveness grounds as treatment for uncomplicated leg ulcers. It says simple dressings and compression bandaging are more appropriate for this.

It also says silver dressings should not be used on acute wounds as there weak evidence to suggest that they delay wound healing.

"There is a better case for using silver dressings for patients with infected burns, but even here, the evidence base is weak," concludes the Bulletin.

The evaluation also discusses the potential for patients to experience hypersensitivity or toxicity due to absorption of silver, and the possibility of dressings contributing to the development of resistant microbes.
'Well reasoned'

New Zealand-based clinical epidemiologist, Dr Andrew Jull of the University of Auckland who is an editor of the Cochrane Wounds Group agrees with the evaluation.

"This is a well reasoned description of the evidence base for silver dressings," says Jull.

"Silver is anti-bacterial in bench-top terms but when it comes to real patients, the quality of evidence is very low."

He believes silver dressings should not be used routinely in leg ulcers and diabetic foot ulcers.

"In other scenarios, I would always say it's a second choice, not a first-line treatment," says Jull.

He says the destruction of skin in serious burns provides greater justification for using silver dressings, but wonders whether antibiotics may be more effective.
Silver dressings defended

But some doctors defend their use of silver dressings to prevent the infection of burn wounds and potentially-lethal toxic shock syndrome.

"The vast majority of burns surgeons in Australia use silver dressings," says Professor Roy Kimble of the University of Queensland in Brisbane, who is also director of burns and trauma at the Royal Children Hospital in Brisbane.

"I'd say that we do have enough evidence to say what we're doing is sound and ethical."

Kimble says there has been an explosion of silver dressings on the market and he agrees many of them have not been properly tested.

But he says he has been involved in a number of studies on the nano-crystalline silver dressing used by most burn units in Australia.

"It's a special silver lattice, which you add water to and it releases silver atom ions and silver atoms. Silver ions kill bacteria and silver atoms almost certainly work as an anti-inflammatory. Both of which are very good for burn wound healing," says Kimble.

"We know that using silver dressings decrease the amount of burn wound infection."

He also says silver dressings are cost effective because they don't have to be changed as often as other dressings.

Kimble says given the available evidence it would be "unethical" to carry out randomised control studies comparing silver dressings to non-antimicrobial dressings.

"I know that I'd be increasing the wound infection rate so I'm not going to do that study," he says.

New Zealand's GM livestock given reprieve
Nano diamonds to become a doctor's best friend
Ocean saltiness reaching new limits
Volcanic ash unlikely to cool planet
Silk forms 'intimate' brain connection
New drug improves hepatitis C outcome
Microbial life discovered in asphalt lake
Green tea may strengthen your teeth
Head-ramming dino had 'gears' in skull
Clever crows show innovative behaviour
Research casts doubt on brain training
Multiple unknowns cloud volcano's impact
Staying fit helps men 'do it longer'
Copenhagen sets Earth for more warming
Solar spacecraft begins study of our Sun
Mixed messages on gene patenting
Gene study finds multiple species of orca
Dreaming boosts learning and creativity
Scientists measure massive ocean current
Genes influence smoking addiction: study
Nanowires create volts of electricity
Fisheries urged to diversify their 'take'
Chimps confront death in human-like ways
Chile to host world's biggest telescope
Trapping light to improve solar cells
Experts debate use of HPV test
Japan to launch 'space yacht'
Sea ice loss key to Arctic warming, study
Australian lasers to track orbiting junk
Thawing nitrous oxide overlooked: study
'Sound bullets' could blast cancer
Lasers could spark clean nuclear power
Seaweed slows black sea snakes down
Asteroid impacts cause crustal crisis: study
Flu jab link to increased H1N1 risk: study
Intestinal germ helps sushi digestion
Researcher closes in on freezing conundrum
Test identifies smokers at highest risk
New species of human found in 'death trap'
'Planet of love' still hot and active
Stress takes its toll on tiny lizard
Scientists record world's tiniest nudge
Cell signals shed light on breast cancer
Parasites behind seasonal allergies
Study finds maternal deaths falling
Pluto's family set to grow tenfold
Diet cuts Alzheimer's risk: study
Whales get physical when seas get rough
'Tweets' could warn of future epidemics
Quolls force-fed toads in survival fight
Researchers question use of silver dressings
Scientists create truly random numbers
Visit Statistics